Hypothesis alternatives for annotating websites with clients
Hypothesis is a free, open source annotation tool that many classes and research groups rely on. When the person annotating is a client reviewing a website you built, a different kind of tool fits better. Here is a fair look at what Hypothesis does well, six alternatives for client review, and prices checked on each company's site on 16 November 2026.
What Hypothesis does well
Hypothesis lets you highlight text on almost any web page and attach a note to it. You sign up for a free account, add the extension from the Chrome Web Store (it also runs in Edge, Brave and Vivaldi), or use a bookmarklet in Firefox and Safari. Notes appear in a side panel next to the page, and you can reply to other people's notes in the same place.
Every note goes either to the public layer, which any Hypothesis user can read, or to a group. Private groups are joined through an invite link, and only signed-in members can read what is posted there. That makes it a natural fit for a seminar reading the same paper, a journalist collecting sources, or a research team marking up articles together.
A few other things it does well:
- It annotates online PDFs and videos as well as web pages, so a whole course reading list can live in one tool.
- It plugs into Canvas, Blackboard, Moodle and D2L, where students annotate assignments with no extra login and instructors track activity from a dashboard.
- It is free for personal use and collaboration, and its code is open source under a BSD licence.
- Your notes follow the text across the web, so you can come back to an article months later and find your highlights waiting.
We covered Hypothesis next to screenshots and review links in how to annotate a web page, so this post skips the basics and looks at the specific case of getting a client to review a site.
Where it falls short for client website reviews
Client review is a different job from reading. You built a page, and you want a client, a manager or a marketing lead to tell you what to change before launch. That job has its own needs, and Hypothesis was designed around another one.
- Each reviewer has to install the extension or bookmarklet and create an account before leaving a single note. Many clients will not, and work laptops often block extensions.
- Notes attach to selected text. Feedback about a button, an image, spacing or a broken layout has no text to hang from, so the client ends up describing where they mean.
- There is no idea of screen sizes. A note about the phone menu looks the same as a note about the desktop header.
- The tool has no task workflow for this kind of work: no assignees, no priority, no approval step at the end of a round.
A class annotating an essay never runs into these limits. Agencies and freelancers chasing sign-off run into all of them, which is why most use a dedicated review tool.
Prices and free plans at a glance
Monthly billing in US dollars, from each company's own pricing page, checked 16 November 2026.
| Tool | Built for | What reviewers need | Free plan | Paid from |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hypothesis | Reading, research, classes | A free account and the extension or bookmarklet | Yes, core annotation and private groups | Education plans by quote |
| HTMLAnnotate | Client review of websites, HTML files, PDFs | The review link | 1 project | $15 a month for 1 person |
| Pastel | Client review of websites and creative work | The review link | 1 user, 1 active canvas | $35 a month for 2 users |
| Markup.io | Review of websites and many file types | The review link | No, 14-day trial | $79 a month for 50 MarkUps |
| ruttl | Website, web app and mobile app feedback | The review link | Up to 5 users, 1 project, 5 pages | $18 per user a month |
| BugHerd | Feedback as tasks on a kanban board | The link, with a script or extension on your side | No, 7-day trial | $50 a month for 5 members |
| Marker.io | Bug reports into Jira, GitHub and similar | A widget on the site or an extension | No, 15-day trial | $59 a month for 3 members |
1. HTMLAnnotate
This is our own tool, so read this entry knowing that. You paste a live or staging link, or upload a single HTML file or a PDF, and get a review link. The real site runs inside the review with its scripts, so menus, sliders and forms behave as they do for visitors. Clients click any element or spot to pin a comment, with no account and nothing to install, and each comment saves a screenshot plus browser and screen details.
Desktop, tablet and phone views keep separate pins, which solves the screen size problem above. Comments can be replied to, resolved, labelled and assigned, clients can suggest text edits directly, and there is an approval step for each version. Paid plans add Slack and webhooks. "Copy for AI" and an MCP server let Claude, ChatGPT or Cursor read the comments and mark them resolved.
Free covers 1 project with unlimited pages, comments and reviewers, and links last up to 14 days. Pro is $15 a month ($12 billed yearly) for one person, with unlimited projects and links that never expire, and a second person is $5 a month. Team is $40 a month ($32 billed yearly) for 5 people, then $5 a month for each extra person, up to 25. The pricing page lists every limit.
It suits freelancers and small agencies whose reviews are websites, landing pages and the occasional PDF. It does not do video or image proofing, and it is no replacement for Hypothesis as a research notebook. You can try the live demo without signing up.
2. Pastel
Pastel gives each site a canvas that clients open from a link. Anyone can comment or view without an account, and guests can reply but cannot create canvases or export comments. Approvals are included on every plan, Free too, and the CSV export carries each comment's status and assignee.
The free plan is 1 user with 1 active canvas. Pro costs $35 a month ($29 a month billed yearly) for 2 users and 3 active canvases. Team is $119 a month ($99 yearly) starting at 5 users, with unlimited canvases and $24 for each extra user. Enterprise is $450 a month for 10 users or more. Paid plans have a 14-day trial.
Pastel is a good pick for a design studio that cares about a polished client experience and keeps a few sites in review at a time. Check the 3-canvas limit on Pro against a busy month. HTMLAnnotate vs Pastel.
3. Markup.io
Markup.io handles live websites alongside images, PDFs, videos and most common file types, which makes it the broadest tool on this list. Guests comment with no sign-up and nothing to download. There is an optional Chrome extension for creating MarkUps with screenshots from your own browser.
There is no free plan, only a 14-day trial on Pro and Business. Pro is $79 a month for 50 MarkUps, $99 for 75 or $129 for 100. Business starts at $499 a month for 200. Every plan includes unlimited users, and extra MarkUps cost $4 each in batches of 10. Paying yearly saves two months.
It fits a larger team that reviews many file types and would rather count reviews than seats. Smaller website teams should estimate how many MarkUps they open in a month first. HTMLAnnotate vs Markup.io.
4. ruttl
ruttl covers live websites, web apps, images, PDFs and native mobile apps, and its site says clients can give feedback on live projects without signing up. Website projects plug into WordPress, Shopify or custom HTML, and mobile app feedback works through an NPM package. Tickets can go to Trello, Slack, Asana, Jira, Zapier or ClickUp.
The free Basic plan allows up to 5 users on 1 project with 5 pages and 1GB of storage. Pro is listed at $18 per user a month for one admin and up to 50 users, with unlimited projects and pages. Business is priced on request. Guests are unlimited on every plan. The pricing page has a yearly toggle but does not show a separate yearly figure, so check it when you sign up.
ruttl makes sense for a team that also needs feedback on a mobile app, or wants a free plan with several seats. Per-user pricing adds up faster than flat team plans once you pass a few people. HTMLAnnotate vs ruttl.
5. BugHerd
BugHerd turns every client comment into a task on a built-in kanban board, with the technical details attached. Clients don't need accounts or logins. BugHerd recommends adding a one-line JavaScript tag to the site, and offers a browser extension for sites where you can't add code.
There is no free plan. The trial lasts 7 days, and BugHerd also offers a 60-day money-back guarantee. Standard is $50 a month ($42 billed yearly) for 5 members, Studio is $80 ($67 yearly) for 10, and Premium is $150 ($125 yearly) for 25. Extra members are $8 a month.
BugHerd works well when developers fix issues from a board and the project manager wants feedback to arrive as tickets. For a quick copy and design review, the board can be more structure than a client round needs. HTMLAnnotate vs BugHerd.
6. Marker.io
Marker.io is a bug reporting tool for websites and web apps. Reporters use a widget on your site or a browser extension, both included on every plan, and clients send feedback without an account or a paid seat. Reports land in tools such as Jira, Trello, Asana and GitHub.
There is no free plan; the trial lasts 15 days with no card. Starter is $59 a month ($39 billed yearly) for 3 members, Team is $199 ($149 yearly) for 15, and Agency is $129 ($99 yearly) for 15 members and up to 50 client projects. Business is custom and billed yearly.
Choose Marker.io when QA and development teams need detailed reports going straight into their tracker. Agencies collecting design and copy notes may find it heavier than they need. HTMLAnnotate vs Marker.io.
When Hypothesis is still the better pick
For some work, none of the tools above come close. Stay with Hypothesis if:
- You are annotating to read and think. Highlighting articles, papers and reports for your own research, and finding those notes again later, is what it was made for.
- You teach. The LMS integration lets students annotate readings inside Canvas, Blackboard, Moodle or D2L without a separate login, and instructors can grade from it on paid plans.
- You want public annotation. Notes in the public layer can be read by anyone with Hypothesis, which suits open peer review, fact-checking and commentary on published work.
- Your group already uses it. A reading group or lab that all have the extension installed has no setup cost, and private groups keep the notes among members.
- Budget is zero and the annotators are willing. It is free for personal use and collaboration, with no limit on notes listed.
Some teams use both: Hypothesis for research and reading, and a review tool for sign-off on the sites they build.
How to choose
Start with who is annotating and why. If it is you or a class working through texts, keep Hypothesis. If it is a client telling you what to change on a website, work through these questions.
- Will reviewers install anything? If the answer is probably not, pick a tool that opens from a link: HTMLAnnotate, Pastel, Markup.io or ruttl. BugHerd and Marker.io need a script or extension, though the client still doesn't need an account. Our list of feedback tools that need no sign-up goes into this in more detail.
- What will they comment on? Clicking a button or image and pinning a note to it is the main thing a client review tool adds over text highlights. Try that on your own page during the trial.
- Do phone comments matter? Check whether mobile notes are kept apart from desktop ones, so you know which layout each comment means.
- How many people on your side create reviews? Clients are free everywhere here, so price depends on your team. One or two people: HTMLAnnotate Pro at $15 or $20, Pastel Pro at $35, or ruttl's free plan. Ten people: compare HTMLAnnotate Team at $65, BugHerd Studio at $80 and Markup.io at $79.
- Where should feedback end up? If developers live in Jira or a kanban board, BugHerd or Marker.io save copying tickets. If you want one list with approvals at the end, a link-based tool is simpler.
- Do you need anything beyond websites? Video and image proofing point to Markup.io or Pastel, and native mobile apps point to ruttl.
Whatever you pick, run one real round with a client who isn't technical before you pay. For the final step of that round, our guide to getting client approval on a website covers how to get a clear yes, and free website annotation tools compares more free options.
Questions
Is Hypothesis free?
Yes for individuals. Hypothesis describes itself as always free for personal use and collaboration, and its free tier includes core annotation and private groups. Its education plans (Bronze, Silver and Gold) add LMS integration, analytics and support, and are priced per student per year on request. Checked on web.hypothes.is on 16 November 2026.
Do clients need a Hypothesis account to annotate?
Yes. Everyone who annotates signs up for a free Hypothesis account, and joining a private group means being signed in and opening the group's invite link. Students using Hypothesis inside Canvas, Blackboard, Moodle or D2L are the exception, since the LMS integration handles login.
Can Hypothesis annotate a staging site?
Through the browser extension, yes, as long as the annotator can open the page in their own browser. The catch for client work is setup: each reviewer installs the extension (or a bookmarklet in Firefox or Safari) and creates an account first. Review link tools such as HTMLAnnotate open the staging link for them.
What is the best free Hypothesis alternative for client feedback?
HTMLAnnotate's free plan covers 1 project with unlimited pages, comments and reviewers, and links last up to 14 days. ruttl's free Basic plan allows up to 5 users on 1 project with 5 pages. Pastel's free plan gives 1 user 1 active canvas. All three let clients comment without an account.
Is Hypothesis open source?
Yes. The Hypothesis server code is public on GitHub under the BSD 2-Clause licence, and the browser client is a separate public project. The company behind it is listed on its site as Annotation Unlimited, PBC.
When should I keep using Hypothesis?
When the notes are about reading: highlighting and discussing articles, PDFs and course texts, running a class or reading group, or adding public annotations anyone can see. It is free for that, works across the web and inside learning platforms, and the alternatives in this post are built for a different job.
Paste your site link, send the review link, and let clients click anything to comment. HTMLAnnotate is free for 1 project.
Start a free review